More Spalding Modifications
On this page of the Guide each of 70 phonograms in the Spalding Method are listed, as well as changes I would suggest incorporating for the reasons given. The committee that devised the 5th Edition changed the order of the presentation of phonograms, so I will go with their suggested order for the purposes here.
a = /a/ (at); /ae/ (navy); /o/ (father) Notation change: Spalding underlines the long vowel sound of the letters a, e, i, o and u, but then numbers those same vowels for third and fourth sounds. I would use the number 2 for the long sound and save underlining for indicating digraphs only.
c = /c/ (can); /s/ (cent) Notation change: Spalding relies on a rule to explain which sound, /c/ or /s/, the phonogram c represents. I would number the second sound with a 2 as well as using the rule.
d = /d/ (lid) No change
f = /f/ (if) No change
g = /g/ (bag); /j/ (gem) Notation change: As with the phonogram c, Spalding relies on a rule to explain which sound the phonogram g represents. Again, I would number the second sound with a 2 and also incorporate the rule.
o = /o/ (odd); /oe/ (open); /oo/ (do) Notation change: See phonogram a
s = /s/ (us); /z/ (as) No change
qu = /k/w/ (quit) No change
b = /b/ (rib) No change
e = /e/ (end); /ee/ (me) Notation change: See phonogram a
h = /h/ (him) No change
i = /i/ (big); /ie/ (silent) Sound change: Add /ee/ (ski) as a third sound and number it 3. Notation change: See phonogram a
j = /j/ (jam) No change
k = /c/ (ink) No change
l = /l/ (lag) No change
m = /m/ (ham) No change
n = /n/ (win) Sound change: Add /ng/ (ink) as a second sound and number it 2.
p = /p/ (map) No change
r = /r/ (rat) No change
t = /t/ (bat) No change
u = /u/ (up); /ue/ (music); /oul/ (put) Sound change: Add /oo/ (truth) and number it 3, moving /oul/ (put) to the fourth position, renumbering it 4. Notation change: See phonogram a
w = /w/ (wit) No change
x = /k/s/ (box) No change
y = /y/ (yet); /i/ (gym); /ie/ (my) Sound changes: 1) Add /ee/ (happy); 2) Drop /y/ (yet) and teach a leading phonogram y to be pronounced with a quick /ee/ sound. Notation changes: Change the order to /ee/ (happy); /ie/ (my); /i/ (gym) and number the second and third sounds with 2 and 3 respectively.
z = /z/ (zest) No change
sh = /sh/ (dish) No change
ee = /ee/ (see) No change
th = /th/ (thin); /the/ (this) No change
ow = /ow/ (how); /oe/ (low) No change
ou = /ow/ (round); /oe/ (soul); /oo/ (you); /u/ (country) No change
oo = /oo/ boot; /oul/ (foot) No change
ch = /ch/ (much); /c/ (school); /sh/ (chef) No change
ar = /ar/ (far) Sound changes: Add the three sounds /or/ (war); /er/ (dollar); /err/ (vary) and number them 2, 3 and 4 respectively.
ay = /ae/ (day) No change
ai = /ae/ (paint) No change
oy = /oy/ (boy) No change
oi = /oy/ (point) No change
er = /er/ (her) Sound change: Add /err/ (very) and number it 2.
ir = /er/ (first) No change
ur = /er/ (nurse) No change
wor = /w/er/ (work) Phonogram change: Drop wor from the list and do not teach it as a phonogram.
ear = /er/ (early) No change
ng = /ng/ (rang) No change
ea = /ee/ (eat); /e/ (head); /ae/ (break) No change
aw = /aw/ (law) No change
au = /aw/ (author) No change
or = /or/ (for) Sound change: Add /er/ (work) and number it 2.
ck = /c/ (neck) No change
wh = /hw/ (when) No change
ed = /e/d/ (graded); /d/ (hummed); /t/ (hopped) Sound change: Drop /e/d/ (graded) as it is two sounds, not one. Notation change: Renumber /t/ (hopped) as 2. /d/ (hummed), being number 1, needs no number then.
ew = /oo/ (grew); /ue/ (few) Notation change: Switch the order, renumbering /oo/ (grew) as number 2.
ui = /oo/ (fruit); /ue/ (suit) Sound change: Drop /ue/ (suit) as modern pronunciation is /oo/ (suit) and the phonogram ui has only one sound now.
oa = /oe/ (boat) No change
gu = /g/ (guess) No change
ph = /f/ (phone) No change
ough = /oe/ (though); /oo/ (through); /u/f/ (rough); /o/f/ (cough); /aw/ (thought); /ow/ (drought) Sound change: Drop /u/f/ (rough) and /o/f/ (cough) as they are both two sounds, not one. Notation change: Renumber /ow/ (drought) as the number 1, /oe/ (though) as 2, /oo/ (through) as 3 and /aw/ (thought) as 4.
oe = /oe/ (toe) No change
ey = /ae/ (they); /ee/ (key); /i/ (valley) Sound change: Drop /i/ (valley) Notation change: Switch /ee/ (key) to the first sound and /ae/ (they) to the second and number it 2.
igh = /ie/ (sigh) No change
kn = /n/ (knot) No change
gn = /n/ (sign) No change
wr = /r/ (wrap) No change
ie = /ee/ (field); /ie/ (pie); /i/ (lilies) Sound change: Drop /i/ (lilies) Notation change: Switch /ie/ (pie) to the first sound and /ee/ (field) to the second and number it 2.
dge = /j/ (bridge) No change
ei = /ee/ (weird); /ae/ (veil); /i/ (forfeit) Sound change: Change /i/ (forfeit) to /e/ (heifer) and teach all of the current /i/ examples as /e/ examples.
eigh = /ae/ (weigh) No change
ti = /sh/ (nation) No change
si = /sh/ (mansion); /zh/ (vision) No change
ci = /sh/ (facial) No change
All of the reasoning behind the changes suggested here will be discussed on the next page of the Guide except the four changes discussed on the page Modifying the Spalding Method.
Next: Reasons for Modifying Spalding, or return to the OnTrack Home Page.